Tuesday, July 22, 2014

McIlroy can't commit...does that matter?

It's hard to be consistently excellent in any sport, especially in the case of an individual sport such as golf.  Teammates can cover for a bad day from one or two others here and there but as anyone who plays golf knows, there is no one to help you out on the course.  For a professional, a bad day means you're not going to win the tournament.  A select few golfers have been able to develop a consistently high level of play over a long period of time.  Tiger Woods was the Number 1 golfer virtually from the time I was aware of golf as a human until his pancake house adventures were discovered in 2009, with only a slight Vijay Singh-fueled blip in the middle.  Jim Furyk seems as if he's been in the top 20 for as long as golf has been played professionally.  It's not easy.  It takes talent, practice, and commitment.
                Commitment is not something that Rory McIlroy  seems to have mastered at this point in his professional career.  He has an absurd amount of talent, so check that box.  His technique (that beautiful whip-like drive) indicates a very high level of practice so no fault there.  His golf is flawless...until it isn't.  Even in the midst of his staggering success, being the best golfer in the world through 2011 and 2012, he has had had some pretty low moments.  He melted down so dramatically at the 2011 Masters that even Greg Norman had to wince.  His title defense at the 2012 US Open was cut two days short by the monster disguised as the Olympic Club course.  He withdrew from the 2013 Honda Classic under bizarre circumstances.  In fact, we can safely characterize the entirety of 2013 as a low point for McIlroy. 
                A lot of outsiders pointed to McIlroy's personal dealings to explain his 2013 collapse, focusing on his tumultuous relationship with former Number 1 tennis player Caroline Wozniacki.  After dumping his high school girlfriend for the Danish tennis pro, his game slipped noticeably (as did Wozniacki's, funnily enough).  She was viewed as a distraction by observers, keeping him from reaching his full potential.
                That's a lie of course, everyone with half a brain knows that McIlroy struggled in 2013 because he changed his clubs in exchange for a bajillion dollar contract with Nike and failed to adjust.  It's an occupational hazard of being near the top of any sport that Nike or Adidas will start throwing huge bags of money at you, and the unwary will trip over those bags.  This was McIlroy's true commitment issue, his decision not to follow through on a long term relationship with old partner Titleist more impactful than his insidious mindgames decision to separate from Wozniacki. 
                But finally after text message breaking up with Wozniacki, then proposing to her, then breaking off the engagement after weddings invitations had been printed, and going through a similar but more fruitful process with his Nike clubs, he won his first major tournament since the PGA Championship in 2012.  In winning the Open Championship this past weekend, McIlroy showed the steady and dominant play that won him both the PGA and the 2011 US Open.  Despite a slight dip on Sunday to keep things interesting, the result of the tournament was never in much doubt after Friday's round.  Now he looks to be on the upswing.

                So maybe McIlroy has proven me wrong after all.  Maybe commitment is overrated in terms of long term sports success.  He dropped the clubs, he dropped the girl, but he's gone right back to winning again.  Maybe we'd like to think that athletes have to hold themselves to certain standards, and that it's about more than just talent.  But talent really does win out where athletics is concerned.   But then again, maybe we're all taking this just a bit too seriously.  He's a 25 year old playing some golf.  He's bound to be kind of a screw-up where life is concerned.  His future is a lot less certain than the result was this past Sunday.  

No comments:

Post a Comment